Brandywine Asset Management founder Michael Dever's "Jackass Investing" is not only entertaining, but also filled with advice that is likely to strike the reader as counter-intuitive. While most folks probably would agree that "buy and hold" is not an effective long-term strategy, readers might be surprised to learn that "buy low and sell high" is a recipe for disaster. The whole book is filled with well-articulated conclusions that are likely to make the reader question his or her previously held conceptions about investing.
The book is organized into 20 "myths", each of which Dever tears to shreds. Along the way, the reader certainly learns what NOT to do, but the book ends with Dever's game plan for how to get a "free lunch" of higher returns with lower risk, with an in-depth description in an accompanying website.
What I liked best about the book was not only the logic and data that Dever used to break down misconceptions about investing, but also the way he gets to the psychological root of these stumbling blocks. For instance, Dever offers a persuasive argument that investing, as opposed to trading, can more resemble gambling. He also shows how monkeys do a better job of predicting the future than so-called experts, yet people still continue to follow the advice of experts. You will have to read the book to learn why!
Dever tells some great stories as he destroys commonly accepted notions about investing. Even if the reader doesn't get his central message, he or she will be thoroughly entertained. I expect, though, that the reader will ultimately understand his key points regarding correlations and drawdowns. Dever does a great job of explaining these concepts in an easy-to-understand way.
After reading Jackass Investing, I think that the individual investor is likely to look at its tagline of "Don't do it. Profit from it." with ambivalence. On the one hand, it's easy to avoid the many mistakes Dever describes. The reader should walk away from this book with a smarter way to think about risk. On the other hand, though, I don't think it's so easy for the small investor to actually profit from the mistakes of the crowd. Dever suggests several different "free lunch" portfolios in the accompanying website, some of which are quite complex. To his credit, though, he slims it down with a "simplified free lunch portfolio" that consists of ETFs and mutual funds and requires just $65K minimum to pursue the strategy. I am not suggesting that his portfolio won't deliver a better risk-adjusted return than more common stock/bond/cash strategies, but the reader is likely to hesitate in implementing it. Fortunately, Dever is intending to update model performance going forward, which I think will be a great way to build confidence in employing his strategies.
I think Jackass Investing is a great read for individuals, but the real value may be for those who are responsible for allocating capital on behalf of institutions and for very wealthy investors who, as Dever admits, are in a better position to pursue some of the strategies he recommends. In fact, after reading the book, I think that plan sponsors should ask themselves why they don't seek out uncorrelated strategies. Dever is a big believer in commodities and futures, and I know from my experience that there is significant institutional bias against these instruments. As Dever explains, volatility, in and of itself, isn't risk, and I think that endowments and pension plans would be well served to explore Dever's arguments more closely.
Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of the book